This was the first beer Kel and I opened from the beertrade. It was a mellow Sunday afternoon and the beer was great daytime
drinker—although it would have been more fitting on a rainy day.
Appearance: Clear brown-to red with a thin off white head
that looks pretty and creamy but falls quickly to a thin film… but can’t blame
a low carbonation beer for being a little shy.
Smell: Rich coffee and bread crusty notes with some roasted
nut tones and a hint of cola sweetness in the background. Pretty aromatic for a
small beer, with a complex depth that fades from fruit to roast and a lot of
layers in between.
Taste: Smooth and rich with more toffee than the nose.
Nicely full without being too sweet (the beauty of the style when done right
IMO). Rich and nutty… almost a hint of poppy seeds. Finish is long and cozy,
clean and light, pleasant.
Mouthfeel: Light bodied with light to moderate carbonation.
I’d say it could use a bit more body—preferably more “cheweyness” from oats or
flaked wheat/barley, but some extra “stickyness” from more c-malts would be
fine too.
Overall: I love the layers of yeast and malt. It is quite
captivating for such a low gravity beer. I’d love to know what is lending the
subtle herbal and cola notes, and I think the super low bitterness (low even
for the style) is a nice touch.
If it were my beer what would I tweak? It’s hard to say
exactly because I don’t know what the recipe looks like, but I’d probably add
some [more?] oats or up the mash temp quite a bit to try to get more body out
of it. And, although I generally stay away from it I may make the [switch?] to
Marris Otter as a base in an effort to bring even more malty flavors to the
party. Really though, I think the yeast choice, malt bill, hopping, and water
treatments are right on.
Any of y’all that haven’t had the pleasure of drinking an
English Dark Mild, go find one!
Really like your comments about how to move forward with version 2, and its exactly what I plan on doing... Kicking up the Pale Chocolate just a touch, mashing higher, and switching out the Briess Mild Malt for Crisp or Simpsons Marris Otter.
ReplyDelete